201 / 228
179
Probably The Finest 1914-S $5 Indian
1603
1914-S. PCGS graded MS-65 PQ.
CAC Approved.
This coin is tied with the
famous Dr. Steven Duckor example that is now in the Simpson Collection. Although the
mintage of 263,000 pieces implies likely availability, this is true only up to the MS-62
grade range. And most of these lower end mint state coins offer subdued luster and
abraded surfaces, as expected. At the choice grade level the 1914-S half eagle is a
true challenge with sparse numbers seen and values approaching five figures. Finer
coins are downright rare, with PCGS noting a scant 6 pieces as MS-64, and a single
MS-64+ in their Population Report. For many years only the Duckor coin appeared to
achieve the gem level, until this splendid coin was submitted recently. Its staggering
quality and glowing mint color earned its rightful place as a tie to the Duckor gem.
Now pictured on the CoinFacts website to represent this issue, collectors far and wide
can view the wonders of this jewel. NGC has similarly graded 6 examples as MS-64,
but only a single example of this date and mint as MS-65. None are finer. Rich golden
toning which both dazzles the eye and radiates the golden iridescence of the surfaces.
Boldly struck throughout, and carefully preserved. The exceptional appeal of this coin
makes us wonder if it was not set aside at the time of issue, as it so clearly stands
head and shoulders above virtually all other known pieces. If you desire the finest,
then here is a coin to make sure to win.
In the Encyclopedia of U.S. Gold Coins 1795 - 1833 by Jeff Garrett and Ron Guth this
date is described as follows “Thus, the 1914-S has earned its place as the most dif-
ficult and rarest issue of the series to find in MS-64 or higher grades. This date should
be considered the key date to the series.” With only two PCGS gem coins known, one
of which is tied up the Simpson Collection, it may well be a long while until another
opportunity arises to obtain a gem of the 1914-S. Hence, if you desire the best, then
the time to act is upon you.
Pop 2; none finer. Tied for the finest at either grad-
ing service (PCGS # 8529)
Estimated Value................................................................................. $70,000-UP
Ex. US Gold from a prominent midwestern family collection.